Food vs. Supplements - What's the difference?
Put two bags of gummies side by side and they might look like the same kind of product. Turn them over and you might see Nutrition Facts on one and Supplement Facts on the other. That heading tells you whether the product is sold as a conventional food or a dietary supplement. The FDA regulates both, and each category has its own rules for what companies must disclose and how they can describe a product’s benefits. FDA: Is It Really “FDA Approved”? A company making a snack has to establish that each added ingredient is lawful for that particular use in food. A company making a dietary supplement follows a separate set of rules for its dietary ingredients. That distinction can change both what goes into a gummy and what the company can say on the package.
An ingredient sold in a supplement is not automatically allowed in a snack
Say a company wants to take a concentrated botanical extract it sells in a supplement and add it to a snack gummy. The fact that the extract is used in a supplement does not establish that it can be used in the snack. For conventional food, an added substance generally needs FDA approval as a food additive unless qualified experts generally recognize it as safe for that particular use, known as GRAS, or another legal exception applies. The intended use matters. A safety basis for a small amount used as a flavoring may not cover a larger amount added to every serving. FDA: Determining the Regulatory Status of a Food Ingredient
In a supplement, qualifying dietary ingredients such as vitamins, minerals and botanical extracts are governed by dietary supplement rules. The company is responsible for safety, and the FDA does not approve the finished supplement for safety or effectiveness before sale. When a supplement contains a new dietary ingredient that requires notification, the company must submit its safety basis to the FDA at least 75 days before introducing the product into interstate commerce. Other ingredients in the supplement, such as sweeteners, still have to comply with applicable food ingredient rules. FDA: New Dietary Ingredients · FDA: Food additive guidance
The rules also limit what a company can promise
A conventional food can describe how its nutrients support a normal body function. For example, a claim about regularity can be based on what the food’s fiber does. A supplement can make a claim about how a dietary ingredient supports normal body function, even when the claimed effect does not come from its nutritional value. The supplement company must have evidence for the claim, include the required FDA disclaimer and notify the FDA within 30 days of first marketing the product with the claim. A claim that a product treats a disease is a drug claim and generally requires the product to meet drug requirements. FDA: Structure/Function Claims
Where Prunies® fits
I created Prunies® as a prune-based snack I could pack in my carry-on. It is sold as a food, so you will find Nutrition Facts on the pouch. A fiber supplement typically has a Supplement Facts panel. One rule the two labels share is what counts as dietary fiber. Naturally occurring fiber that remains intact in plant foods counts, and the FDA looks for evidence of a beneficial effect when determining whether an isolated or synthetic carbohydrate qualifies. If you are comparing two gummies for fiber, look at the grams per serving, what a serving actually is and which ingredient provides the fiber. FDA: Dietary Fiber on Nutrition and Supplement Facts Labels